UPSB v4
Battlezone / i.suk vs i.suk [left hands]
-
Date: Sat, Aug 13 2011 16:39:20
please comment on which video you think is better and give reasons ^^ Round 1 [video=youtube;kSgLogIF_ZA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSgLogIF_ZA[/video] Round 2 [video=youtube;KgS-QUAcxm8]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KgS-QUAcxm8[/video]
-
Date: Sat, Aug 13 2011 17:04:47
Round 1 was definitely better in appeal..due to lighting and stuff =/ but spinning wise r2 wins hands down
-
Date: Sat, Aug 13 2011 18:01:02
imo, round1 is better because of the linking of difficult tricks and the variety of tricks
-
Date: Sat, Aug 13 2011 18:17:25
Supergirl wrote: imo, round2 is better because of the linking of difficult tricks and the variety of tricks
fixed -
Date: Sat, Aug 13 2011 18:56:13
Alvaris wrote: fixed
? -
Date: Sat, Aug 13 2011 21:17:59
i.suk is just butthurt cause he lost in the summer tourny -.-' *there there, pats on i.suk's head*
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 01:17:15
I voted for i.suk.
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 03:51:05
I voted for i.suk,too. I think i.suk is better than i.suk.so I'm sure i.suk will beat i.suk.
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 05:08:40
+1 for i.suk
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 05:15:52
I like your 1st combo more, it's smoother and more appealing to me xD Yes also the lighting (but not so important) P/s : your difficulty in the 2nd combo was very high though @.@
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 05:18:16
@TheAafg actually, no he's trying to find out why his r2 marks was lower than r1, hence he put more time in r2. k let me explain what he's trying to say: his excecution was barely higher than a guy who nearly dropped his pen in finisher, and r2 execution>r1 no doubt. judges didnt submit on time, he thought enter also shouldve won\not by a landslide amount, appeal shouldve been higher because of dark lighting(see some jeb spinners)... etc. so he's finding out how to improve his combos ^^
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 06:23:52
I thought round one was better. In terms of execution and creativity both were the same. Both were shaky and and had elements which was unsmooth. Creativity was minimal. No doubt, round 2's difficulty was higher, however round 1 had better presentation in terms of lighting and variety. One big factor on why round 1 was better to me was that in round 2, you used a lot of your content from round 1 (about 3 to 6 important aspects and linkages). To me its very important in tournaments that each combo doesn't get too repetitive. Even if you don't factor in the repetition of combos thingy, both combos are pretty even so, to me its not that surprising that round 2 got lower than round 1 'cause it could have gone either way.
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 07:22:23
TheAafg wrote: i.suk is just butthurt cause he lost in the summer tourny -.-' *there there, pats on i.suk's head*
i expected the loss, but i am a bit mystified as to how my R1 combo is meant to be better than R2 -
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 07:40:17
Round 2 over Round 1. My reason is simply that your minor setbacks in the first video were much more apparent than the ones in the second video. Difficulty didn't play much of a factor for me since both were relatively the same in its' terms. I also didn't take the lighting into account since it didn't really affect my acknowledgements for either combo by a significant portion.
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 14:33:33
I liked the 2nd one more, despite the lighting. First one has more slips and got stuck several times. :)
-
Date: Sun, Aug 14 2011 14:50:27
2nd one wouldve been better, if this was not a tournament like hippo said, I think u used multiple material in the second round that was used already in the first round so as in terms of judging, probably cuz of the recycled material u got a lower score say if this wasn't a tournament, or these combos were put in different tournaments ur 2nd combo wouldve been marked higher than ur 1st
-
Date: Thu, Aug 18 2011 09:56:31
2nd... for sure
-
Date: Fri, Aug 19 2011 12:20:47
round1 imo
-
Date: Fri, Aug 19 2011 12:26:24
Round 2, so obvious. >.>