UPSB v4

General Discussion / Most controversial battles

  1. hoiboy
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 00:46:21

    In your opinion, what are the most controversial pen spinning battles? Eriror vs. Toro WC08 s777 vs. Spinnerpeem WT09

  2. KTrinh93
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 01:59:43

    Depends on what you mean by "controversial." The most recent one I remember is WC10 Darcy vs Gisele 8 in the Speed theme.

  3. Riley
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 01:59:48

    Spinnerpeem vs Minwoo WT 09, many people wanted Minwoo. They were both really good, just different styles.

  4. k-ryder
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 02:09:05

    Riley wrote: Spinnerpeem vs Minwoo WT 09, many people wanted Minwoo. They were both really good, just different styles.
    was that controversial, or just close? theres a slight difference i wasn't too involved in WT09, only tornament i followed closely was last years (this year's actually) WC and i agree with gisele/darcy speed battle i define controversial as: 1. a result from the judges going opposite to an almost unanimous public opinion see, with that definition, i can't say that darcy/gisele was controversial i need to think of a part 2. of the definition

  5. casual
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 02:30:40

    meteor vs a13x wt09 ssEno vs x1213 wt09

  6. happy_happy
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 03:19:38

    KTH [PDS] vs. Eriror [UCPSB] WT07 final

  7. i.suk
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 03:51:24

    dammit, sko1 said the 2 i were thinking of -.- A13X vs Dongza WT09 Asian Cup 2008 round 2 (not really battle, but there was quite an argument over taru's (?) judging of chinese collab video for that round) Eriror vs Supawit WT09

  8. KTrinh93
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 03:57:30

    k-ryder wrote: i define controversial as: 1. a result from the judges going opposite to an almost unanimous public opinion see, with that definition, i can't say that darcy/gisele was controversial
    I define controversial as either what you said, some sort of unfair judging of some sorts that might skew the results one way or another, or an invalid thing that's taken as valid or vice versa. In any case, I still think the Darcy/Gisele 8 round still falls under the "controversial" area because a lot of people thought that Gisele sped up his video and that he might be DQ'd because of it. But when the judges said that he won, quite a few people still thought that he shouldn't have won that because they still believed that he sped his video up. That's just my opinion though.

  9. Frip
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 04:07:20

    taru's bullshit judging in the final of AC08.

  10. hoiboy
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 04:35:59

    Frip wrote: taru's bullshit judging in the final of AC08.
    It was

  11. RR24
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 08:07:39

    i think in all speed videos they should put a clock with visible movement of its hands to see if they sped up or not also Littleboy [BPSC] VS Supawit127 [THPSC] i forget what theme and tourny lol

  12. Loanshark
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 12:51:45

    AoD1 vs. Scott Shaputis

  13. neoknux_009
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 14:29:13

    its g2g be minwoo vs peem. [video=youtube;MZ-OUOnbP6I]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ-OUOnbP6I[/video] come on, off by 1 point? and its the world tournament finals? thats heavy stuff. @RR24 it was this years tourney. it was difficulty theme.

  14. Zombo
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 15:16:57

    ERIROR VS LORDBOJO (JUDGE 3) 12ve vs s777 WT09R1 kam vs NEPTUNE (PMWT Finals)

  15. Erirornal Kraione
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 15:32:00

    Zombo wrote: ERIROR VS LORDBOJO (JUDGE 3)
    Wrong battle. :o

  16. Zombo
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 15:42:30

    Erirornal Kraione wrote: Wrong battle. :o
    what? ...

  17. Erirornal Kraione
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 15:46:09

    http://z15.invisionfree.com/UCPSB/index.php?showtopic=7252 This was the judge 3 one, right?

  18. Zombo
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 16:15:39

    oh right hmm forgot who the 000 was your battle was the one where fratleym started ranting

  19. Mage In Black
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 20:20:27

    Meh, taru's BS judging ruined the AC.

  20. Hippo2626
    Date: Sun, Oct 24 2010 23:21:26

    WC10R3 Creativity Stuhl versus Twister